Talk:Meteor Fall

Of course I usually think all that Diana says it's true, but the thing is that we don't know her sources. It's not only the Encyclopedia, but the Reading doesn't even include it (since it's a movie-and-manga only spell), and in the Slayers Return guidebook only the name is mentioned (I took the kanjis from there), but it doesn't say anything about it. Unless it's mentioned in some interview we don't know about, I suppose Diana may think it's astral magic since it's kind of like a summoning, but anyway, we can't take what she says as granted if we don't know where the read about that. I think the best we could do here is mention that it may be an astral spell, but that we aren't entirely sure. --shansito 17:07, April 22, 2011 (UTC)
 * Diana got her spell list from a different Japanese site and translated it - and actually, it does contain numerous errors. :) (Like Vu Vraimer being black magic.) I by no means want to take everything she says for granted. I just think that, when we don't have any other reference, we can use her categorization because she generally had access to a wider range of sources than we do. (Was Slayers Return based on a Slayers Special story, for instance? That could serve as an explanation.)
 * It is too bad QP/Diana's email no longer works. :( Asking her would be the best way to get this solved. --Pip25 20:23, April 22, 2011 (UTC)


 * That "Saillune Royal Library" or something like that, you say? That was another good site, yep. I guess most of their info come fron interviews and actual reading of the novels, that may help a lot. About Return being based on a novel I can garantee you that all the movies were original works (remember that, mostly thanks to Tokitama, we have access to summaries of almost all the SP novels, and I've compilated titles, scans and some info of the last Special novels and the Smash novels too). But yes, it's a pitty she dissapeared :( --shansito 20:33, April 22, 2011 (UTC)